How Long Will My Money Last? The Withdrawal Math Behind the Answer

How Long Will My Money Last? The Withdrawal Math Behind the Answer

TL;DR: “How long will my money last” is answered by three inputs and one interaction between them: starting balance, withdrawal rate, and real return. Divide the balance by the annual withdrawal to get a naive answer, then correct it — because a return above inflation extends the runway and a return below it shortens it dramatically. The naive division is only accurate when the return exactly matches inflation, which is rare.

Start with the naive answer

The simplest calculation ignores returns entirely: balance divided by annual spending.

A balance of 600,000 with withdrawals of 40,000 lasts 15 years. That is a useful anchor and it is also almost always wrong, in one direction or the other, because it assumes the money sits in a drawer.

Two things it ignores. Money invested earns a return, which extends the runway. Inflation raises spending over time, which shortens it. Whether the real answer is longer or shorter than 15 years depends on which effect is larger — and that is the entire question.

The one correction that matters: real return

Comparing a nominal return to nominal spending is the most common error, and it produces answers that are too optimistic.

The fix is to work in real terms: subtract inflation from the return, and treat withdrawals as constant in today’s money.

If the portfolio earns 7 percent and inflation runs at 3 percent, the real return is roughly 4 percent. Using 7 percent against withdrawals that grow at 3 percent is arithmetically equivalent only if you do it consistently; using 7 percent against flat withdrawals overstates the runway by a wide margin.

The precise relationship is (1 + nominal) ÷ (1 + inflation) − 1, which for 7 percent and 3 percent gives 3.88 percent rather than 4. The difference looks trivial and compounds over decades.

With a 600,000 balance, 40,000 withdrawn annually, and a 4 percent real return, the money lasts indefinitely — because the withdrawal rate equals the real return. At a 3 percent real return it lasts about 24 years. At 1 percent, about 18. That sensitivity is the reason the estimate is a range rather than a number.

Why sequence of returns matters

Two portfolios with identical average returns can last very different lengths of time depending on the order the returns arrive in.

A portfolio that falls 20 percent in the first two years, while you are withdrawing, has less capital left to recover with. The same returns in reverse order — gains first, losses later — leave the portfolio in a much better position, because the withdrawals during the bad years came from a larger base.

This is why a constant-return calculation is optimistic. It assumes a smooth path through a volatile one, and the volatility is not neutral for someone taking money out.

The practical consequence: any estimate that assumes a single steady return should be treated as a midpoint, with the realistic outcome varying by several years in either direction. A plan that works only if the estimate is exactly right does not work.

The withdrawal-rate shortcut

A widely used rule of thumb reverses the calculation: divide the balance by the withdrawal rate to estimate how much you can sustain.

The familiar 4 percent figure implies a 25-times multiple — 600,000 supports 24,000 a year. It was derived from historical data with a specific portfolio mix and a 30-year horizon, and it is a planning starting point rather than a guarantee.

Three caveats worth knowing.

It was calibrated for a 30-year retirement. For a 40-year horizon, the sustainable rate is lower; for 20 years, higher.

It assumes a specific asset mix. A cash-only portfolio cannot sustain 4 percent.

It is a probability statement, not a promise. The original research described success rates, not certainties, and the failures clustered in particular historical periods.

Using a lower rate as a stress test — running the numbers at 3 percent as well as 4 — tells you how much margin you have.

The inputs a calculator needs

If you are going to model this properly, five inputs are required.

  • Starting balance — total investable assets, excluding a home you live in
  • Annual withdrawal — net of any pension or benefit income, in today’s money
  • Expected return — a realistic long-run figure for your asset mix, not last year’s
  • Inflation assumption — typically 2.5 to 3 percent for long-run planning
  • Horizon or age — the period you need the money to cover

The two most frequently misused are expected return and withdrawal. Expected return is usually set too high, using a bull-market figure; withdrawal is usually set too low, because it omits irregular costs like replacing a car, a roof, or a medical expense that insurance does not cover.

A useful discipline is to add a lumpy-expense line rather than pretending those costs do not exist. They arrive on a schedule loosely correlated with nothing, and each one is large.

What the answer is actually good for

The output is not a date. It is a sensitivity check.

Run it three times: a pessimistic real return, a central one, and an optimistic one. If all three give a comfortable margin, the plan is robust. If only the optimistic case works, you have found the risk in the plan, and the response is to reduce withdrawals, work longer, or hold more of the balance in reserve.

That framing is more useful than a single number, because it separates the parts you control from the parts you do not. Return is not controllable; withdrawal rate and horizon are.

If you want to see how the runway changes as you adjust the withdrawal, a how long will my money last calculator applies the compounding directly rather than approximating with a division, which is the difference between an anchor and an answer.

The short version

Balance divided by withdrawal is the anchor. Correct it by using real return, then adjust for sequence risk, which always makes the realistic answer worse than the smooth one. The 4 percent rule is a 30-year starting point, not a guarantee. Run three scenarios and plan against the pessimistic one.